August 11, 2005 journal, Evidence of Harm,
mercury in vaccines and autism epidemic, a book is written and a medical
controversy erupts in a major war for and against vaccines.
David
Kirby's book reviews "Kirby follows the tug of war against the government health
agencies and the parents and their supporters, Kirby does an admirable job of
clarifying most of the scientific background but doesn't offer his own views on
the debate-although he makes the unassailable point that American health
agencies lagged in calculating the amount of mercury being injected in
babies". The New York Times and the International Herald
Tribune. Kirby’s portrayal manages to make his protagonists seem far
from crazy. He may have been deriding as
dangerous anti-vaccination zealots, but Kirby sets his focus on mercury based
vaccine preservative thimerosal against ‘modern science’s near religious faith in all things genetic. The battle rages on, and while Evidence of Harm
offers no pro-spect of a truce, it does provide
crystal clarity on an often misunderstood side of the arg-ument".
The Washington post.
"Evidence of Harm is a gripping investigation. Much like the 9/1-1 Commission report, it is
an alarming page turner. Keep your eyes
on California, where autism cases are closely tracked. If autism related diagnosis decline over the
next year are two following the introduction of thimerosal-free
vaccines, the finding will further fuel this simmering controversy. Newsday". <C:|Document~1> " one controversy looks likely to
fester. Big Pharma
would love to put it to rest, but the publication of a well re-searched book is
likely to push it to the fore. It isn't
a search to say big Pharma fortunes are tethered in
part to the Amazon.com sales rank of Evidence of Harm. If a link is found, the potential liability
makes asbestos litigation look like belonging to a small claims court. Whichever side the reader ends up believing,
Evidence of Harm makes one thing clear: This is an issue that will not go
away". -Financial Times. "Kirby delivers a well written story that weaves
in startling facts and takes you on a roller coaster ride into homes and
families devastated by autism. It tells
tales of government bureaucracy and political cronyism that, if true, are
appalling. It took me several weeks to
read Evidence of Harm. Maybe it was the
detail-filled narrative from the parents point of view that made me put the
book down every so often and walk away. I shared their pain, their anger, their
feeling of helplessness. –Broomberg News. “Perhaps,
as evidence accumulates, the thimerosal theory may be
validated. Perhaps
not. Inquiry into the etiology
and treatment of autism continues, though the seeming finality of the IOM report
may stifle important research into environmental causes. Kirby’s book, as biased
as it is, "prompts us to dig deeper into this vital issue. One can only
hope that medical and lay readers alike will react to the book responsibly,
with both skepticism and an open mind". The lanchet. An engrossing David and Goliath story in which the giant is an amalgamation
of big government bureaucrats and pharmaceutical lobbyists. Walking the middle line, Kirby’s book remains one of the most
thoroughly researched accounts of the thimerosal
controversy thus far. Its accessible in its handling of medical topics and compelling
in its recounting of the parents fight to ad- vance
their agenda in the face of both political and scientific
roadblocks". From
Publishers Weekly, starred review.
"A riveting new book that examines this controversial, but bio-logical
plausible link, Evidence of Harm lines up the known evidence while telling the
stories of a handful of determined parents forced to become their own
detectives. You will get eye opening glimpses into the trenches where once normally
developing kids slid into the shuttered world of autism and where their parents
refuse to be bounced off-the-walls of seemingly impenetrable bureaucracies. Highly recommended. Knight
Ridder News."